Title: “That’s My Story and I’m Sticking to It”
Text: Mark 4:1-34
Day: 2011-12 Narrative Lectionary
Date: January 15, 2012
You can almost imagine the setup to this little scene in our Gospel reading this morning. “What is the kingdom of God like?” they ask Jesus.
He could say some pat little answer about angels and streets of gold and whatnot…but he doesn’t.
He could explain with some deep theological jargon about the eschatological impacts of God’s impending reign and how proleptically we are able to experience it here and now…but he doesn’t.
No, instead he answers this question with something unexpected: a story. SEVERAL stories, in fact. And to us (and presumably to the people of Jesus’ day) we’re left wondering what kind of answer that really is. I mean, did YOU think that these parables answered the question? I didn’t. Neither did the disciples, apparently! So, what gives?
David Lose, a Professor at Luther Seminary, helpfully outlines the importance of story as a helpful answer to a question in a book entitled “Making Sense of Scripture.” (I have it, if anyone wants to borrow it.) In the book, he invites us to imagine that we’re on a first date. “How do you get to know the person you’re dating better?” he asks. You ask questions, is the obvious response. But he challenges that answer by asking another: Do you ask “fact” questions? Do you ask for facts about themselves? Age, what they do for a living, what their favorite color is, how much they weigh? (Maybe not that one!) The answer, of course, is that you do some of that, sure; but for the most part you want the other person to talk about themselves. In other words, in answer to the question “Who are you?” you are looking for a story. That will tell you more about that person than any “fact” you might get out of them. You’ll learn all about their family history, like-dislikes, pet-peeves, what makes them happy or sad, and even – by listening to their accent – where they come from ethnically or socio-economically! And none of that comes from factual questions. It all comes from stories.
David Lose says “There’s a kind of narrative truth about who we are and what we believe that’s at least as important as the facts we share. But you can’t prove this kind of truth. [Instead], over time you can experience the truth of [this narrative]…The point is, [that facts] aren’t the only kind of truths that matter to us.” Sometimes narrative truths are more telling…
I get this. It makes sense to me. If I were holding Lydia, say, and a stranger came up and asked me who she was, I could easily say “She’s my daughter.” But that hardly gets at who she is. It doesn’t go into her adoption story, or the tumultuous and heart-wrenching six weeks of the paternity case we went through, or the relinquishment and reuniting that we endured, or her goofy personality, or love for books and dogs, or her uncanny ability to growl like a lion from time to time. If you want to know about Lydia, I mean really know her, I’ll have to tell you a story.
The same thing happens for us Lutherans. I don’t know about you, but when people ask about my profession – what I do for a living – I’m always a little reluctant to say that I’m a pastor. It brings about either a lot of unwanted attention or special treatment. But when I do respond by saying that I’m a Lutheran pastor, I’m always a little more wary of the second question that inevitably comes next: What’s a Lutheran?
Have you ever been asked that before? How would you respond? A “reformed Catholic?” “Catholic lite?” “Someone who follows the teachings of Martin Luther? All of those may work depending on with whom you are speaking, but none of them really answers the question. If you want to know what a Lutheran is, you’re gonna have to listen to a story.
And so it was apparently for Jesus. When he wanted to teach people about the Kingdom of God. He did so in a story. He gathers the huge crowd around him and notices that the group is so large he has to get out on a boat so that everyone has room to hear him on the beach. And once he steadies himself, he clears his through and he begins. “Ahem…The Kingdom of God,” he says, “is like the story of a extravagant farmer who sows seed everywhere – in rocky soil, in thorns, along a path, and in healthy soil. Most of it dies, but some of it grows and it results in a huge crop!” At that point, I imagine a dramatic pause as Jesus scans the crowd, looking for even the slightest sign of comprehension. Not seeing any, he continues, “The Kingdom of God is like a light that is brought out from under a bushel basket so that it can illumine the whole world. [Pause...] The Kingdom of God is like a surprise crop that springs up overnight. [Pause...] The Kingdom of God is almost as undetectable as a mustard seed, yet when it is full grown it can’t be missed.”
The scene is set up in such a way that we might imagine that Jesus could go on and on giving examples and stories and parables about the Kingdom of God. And, indeed, in other places he does just that. The Kingdom of God is like a city on a hill. It’s like yeast in a batch of dough. It’s like this… It’s like that… Over and over and over again…story after story.
It might make us feel a bit uncomfortable, I suppose, to never get a direct answer. It certainly makes the original disciples uncomfortable – and according to our Gospel lesson this morning – Jesus tried his best to make things as plain as possible for them, and they still didn’t get it! But maybe “getting it” from Jesus’ point of view isn’t just assenting to a bunch of facts. Maybe “getting it” from Jesus’ point of view isn’t about codifying it by writing it down in black and white. Maybe “getting it” – from Jesus’ point of view – is…well, maybe it’s kind of like taking the Kingdom of God out on a first date. It’s about spending time with it and letting the stories open and reveal a truth that facts alone cannot tell.
That way, when we’re asked about it ourselves, we might be able to better respond in ways that help it to make sense to us and our modern-day context.
What is the Kingdom of God like? Well, for you desert-dwellers: it’s like a drop of rain in a scorching, dry desert that makes the plants come to life. For you computer-geeks: It’s like a computer code of 0′s and 1′s so that one little change will affect the whole computer program. For you quilters: It’s like a small, purple square in the middle of a white quilt that – when washed – bleeds and transforms the entire quilt into a fine shade of blue.
“Is that true?” people may ask. “Well,” you may respond, “that’s my story, and I’m stickin’ to it.”
Amen.
